أسمهان تروي قصتها

Admin - منذ 4 سنوات

من ارشيف تعليقات القراء 2008

name: H.F.
Asmahan tells her story
The book describes a great singer and actress who impressed millions of people in the Middle East during her very short life in art as a drug dependent woman, addictive, indifferent without human heart. This book is very depressive and seems to harbor hatred against this lady. Instead the life of Asmahan should be linked to the perfection of songs together with her brother Farid and her pioneer two films at that. It seems that the writer used the disaster of others to get popular at that time as some journalist used to do. If really, the writer of these notes in the form of a book was a friend of Asmahan, he would never publish such notes. It is non ethical. Unfortunately, in Egypt it is very profitable to make fortune on the expense of dead people, as one popular Journalist makes fortune in various media by publishing about Gamal abd el Nasser during the last years. Please leave those people lie in peace and “ozkoru Mahasen Mawtakom”
However, the book documents very well for that historical period of people’s nonproductive and empty life in Egypt

name: Ali Tal
The thumbnail social history alluded to by Mohamd Eltabei in his book ‘Asmahan, Tells Her Story’ is less of a biography of the great singer and more of a picture of Egypt’s aristocracies during the long dying years of monarchy. Maybe this was not intended. Nonetheless, the first thing that struck me in the book was the apparently unshakable belief of Mohamd Eltabei in the royal political system which the author made it sound better and somewhat it appeared more authentic and suitable for Egypt. Nasser’s agrarian reforms which caused a massive population movement to the cities, very quickly altered the social mix of the urbanised centres, rabidly burying the old system. It was into this sector of the privileged few that poor Asmahan strived to rise. However, according to the narrative this social climber totally failed. The book painted our singing legend as a sad, lowly and pathetic woman who seemed to have walked blindly from one catastrophe into another that was waiting just round the corner. Perhaps Asamhan was and still is the most inventive singer in the Arab world and as such she will be remembered. Dying only at 32 years of age, she left behind her a legacy that will continue to be an inspiration for all artists for generations yet to come.

name: انتصاربوراوى
قرأت الكتاب منذ ايام وهو كتا ب جميل جدا فيه وصف موضوعى لشخصية اسمهان الحقيقية من الداخل وكما لم يعرفها احد وسرد موثق لكثير من محطات حياتها كتاب ساحر وجميل مكتوب بأسلوب صحفى رشيق وممتع